Let commenters get an email when someone replies to them or posts a new comment. Double opt-in, one-click unsubscribe and an importer.
Alternatives to replyMail
Plugins below are selected for functional relevance and current directory signals. Active-install counts do not affect this ranking.
Relevant replacements
WordPress plugins with similar use cases
Compatibility and update metadata provide context, not a quality guarantee. Review each plugin’s details for your site.
Disqus Comment Systemv3.1.6
Disqus is the web's most popular comment system. Use Disqus to increase engagement, retain readers, and grow your audience.
Reliable WordPress email delivery with multiple providers, two connections, Return Path, Reply-To and visual AND/OR routing.
Comments – EchoThreadv1.5.2
A fast, privacy-first Disqus alternative for WordPress: threaded comments, reactions, and ML spam filtering. No ads, no tracking, no data resale.
Dadsoo Ajax Commentv4.0.1
AJAX-powered comments with threaded replies, like/dislike voting, and full Elementor widget support.
Reply-To for WP_Mailv2.0.3
Configure different "Reply-To" addresses by email context with validation, modern tabbed UI, and automatic migration.
This plugin allows visitors to subscribe to get answers to their comments via e-mail.
Take full control of WordPress emails and notifications. Replace default messages, add custom triggers, and send alerts via email, webhook, Slack, and …
Silences the notification emails that WordPress sends to the site administrator, and leaves every other email on your site alone.
This plugin will allow you to add subscribe notification checkbox to comments on your site.